The final report of the Select Committee on the 2026 Commonwealth Games Bid has been tabled in the Legislative Council of the Victorian Parliament
The report is scathing of the Victorian Government’s process but agrees that the Victorian Government’s decision to withdraw from hosting the Commonwealth Games in July 2023 was the right decision at the time.
One should also note the makeup of this Upper House committee – 3 Labor, 2 Liberal, 1 National, 1 Green, 1 One Nation and the chairman is a Libertarian. 6 represent country areas and 3 are metropolitan.
This is the Inquiry summary – the full report runs to 275 pages and can be accessed here.
FINDING 1: The Victorian Government’s proposed 2026 multi-city regional Commonwealth Games was overly ambitious and not feasible in the timeframe, which was shorter than previous Games. This was primarily due to:
• inadequate planning and consultation
• failures in departmental processes and communication
• poor ministerial oversight and accountability
• lack of appropriate infrastructure in regional areas
• logistical issues caused by the proposed multi-city model.
FINDING 2: The Victorian Government’s withdrawal from hosting the 2026 Commonwealth Games was a direct result of a series of failures during the bid and project approval stages. Key stages where the bid should not have progressed were:
• approval of the business case, which was not prepared in an adequate timeframe and based on incomplete data and flawed assumptions
• budget approval, where the Department of Treasury and Finance supported recommendations to host the Games despite highlighting concerns that the actual costs would likely exceed the quantifiable benefit of the Games.
FINDING 3: Failures by key decision makers within the Victorian Government led to withdrawing from hosting the 2026 Commonwealth Games. This includes departments, which supported the progression of the bid, and Ministers, who ultimately approved the bid.
FINDING 4: The Victorian Government’s decision to withdraw from hosting the 2026 Commonwealth Games was the correct decision at that time. Based on the advice provided by the Department of Treasury and Finance, progressing further would have risked considerable costs associated with cancelling major building and supply contracts.
FINDING 5: The high cost and inability to host the Commonwealth Games should have been discovered earlier, highlighting a distinct lack of due diligence and robust planning that never occurred.
FINDING 6: The Victorian Government’s decision to withdraw from hosting the 2026 Commonwealth Games was a result of a series of failures at a departmental and ministerial level. A hasty political decision was made by the then Andrews Labor Government to support the Commonwealth Games in the proposed multi-city model, but the Government did not undertake proper due diligence.
FINDING 7: The Committee concludes that proper processes were truncated or not undertaken at all, and warnings were not heeded by the Victorian Government and government agencies.
FINDING 8: The modelling relied upon by the Andrews Labor Government was inadequate and clearly flawed and the processes and analysis relied upon by government were also flawed.
FINDING 9: The officers in the Department of Premier and Cabinet, Department of Jobs, Skills, Industry and Regions and Department of Treasury and Finance do bear a share of the responsibility for the decision to withdraw. However, ultimately the responsibility must be directly shouldered by the then key ministers, Hon Daniel Andrews, Hon Jacinta Allan MP, Hon Martin Pakula, Hon Tim Pallas, as well as members of the Expenditure Review Committee and the Cabinet. These senior people did not properly manage the process of obtaining the Commonwealth Games and the associated due diligence.
FINDING 10: Noting that Cabinet was the ultimate decision-maker, the Cabinet process, including the role of the Expenditure Review Committee, has been shown to be inadequate and flawed.
FINDING 11: The Department of Treasury and Finance failed in its central responsibility to ensure that well-resourced and solid information was available to support informed Cabinet decision-making, and that due diligence was undertaken in the early decision-making process. The Department of Jobs, Skills, Industry and Regions failed in its role to present a viable plan for the event.
FINDING 12: Despite repeated recommendations from relevant departments and Victoria 2026 to revise the scope of the 2026 Commonwealth Games due to concerns about cost escalations, the Victorian Government refused to do so.
FINDING 13: The Victorian Government’s decision to withdraw from hosting the Commonwealth Games in July 2023 was the right decision at the time.
FINDING 14: There is no evidence that the Victorian Government investigated a Melbourne-based Commonwealth Games option.
FINDING 15: Fifteen events and three para events that were included in the Victoria 2026 Commonwealth Games program are not present in the Glasgow Games Program.
FINDING 16: Pinnacle events, such as the Commonwealth Games, are an effective pipeline for attracting and training volunteers. The Victorian Government’s decision to withdraw from the Games has impeded this and likely resulted in a reduction of sporting volunteers.
FINDING 17: The Victorian Government’s decision to withdraw from hosting the Commonwealth Games had a considerable negative impact on the morale of regional Victoria, which was not confined just to the host cities.
FINDING 18: The Committee agrees with the Victorian Auditor-General that the $6.9 billion cost estimate used to justify the cancellation of the Commonwealth Games was overblown and not transparent. The Committee notes that the Victorian Government was not forthcoming with accurate and timely information.
FINDING 19: When the host contract was cancelled, there was significant national concern that the decision would harm Victoria’s reputation as a host for sporting and other major events. However, there is no immediate evidence to suggest significant harm to Victoria’s reputation in the short term.
FINDING 20: Victoria enjoys a unique position as the host of several major events. It is the Victorian Government’s responsibility to maintain this reputation by actively providing assistance and maintaining readiness to host events. Failures such as the withdrawal from the Commonwealth Games risk undermining Victoria’s perception as an active host.
RECOMMENDATION 1: Subject to the learnings from the Commonwealth Games withdrawal, the Victorian Government should continue to pursue events that are of benefit to Victoria.
FINDING 21: The $2 billion regional package has not yet been fully delivered. Any impact will have to be assessed in the light of the actual delivery.



