Peter Jones looks at the “Outside Your Control” factors impacting our events.
During a recent discussion session with first-year event management students, I presented the following examples of events that have recently confronted their own unique challenges and discussed what we could learn from them.
Firstly, the Moomba Parade, which this year, for the first time in its 50-year history, was cancelled due to extreme weather conditions. I asked the students what they thought the driving force behind this decision was. I was intrigued by some of the initial comments which included “can’t the public just go and sit in the shade,” however when we got back to the core issue we agreed it wasn’t just about the comfort of the public but also the safety of parade participants with a vast majority being community groups who had donated their time.
The primary responsibility of any event organiser is to provide a safe workplace for attendees and participants. The decision, which was the correct one, made by the City of the Melbourne illustrates this commitment. Whilst the majority of participants may have wanted to continue, the potential risk of even one person collapsing due to heat exhaustion was too great to ignore. You can imagine the outcry in the media if something had gone wrong, especially at an event organised by a council.
There would of course been the discussion about the budget implications but I’ve never seen that issue override safety in similar circumstances and obviously, it did not determine the final decision.
Secondly, there is the story that has arisen about the staging of the opening ceremony for this year’s Paris Olympics. For the first time in the history of the Olympics, the ceremony is going to be staged, not in a stadium, but along the Seine River with more than one million spectators expected to line the banks.
Although Melbourne held part of its 2006 Commonwealth Games Ceremony on the Yarra River, this has not been replicated at an Olympic level. A brilliant concept but organisers are now faced with the challenge of how to secure a site this large and the cost implications of trying to achieve a safe environment. You can imagine what the risk team must be considering to meet all the key stakeholder’s objectives.
There is currently discussion about reducing the potential footprint simply to address these issues. While it’s regrettable, how can we prevent people from attending when not all viewing spots are secure? This raised the question asked by one of the students of who is driving the design of events like these: the creative team or the risk team and what ongoing role do they play.
The third topic was the recent issues forcing the cancellation/postponement of many of Australia’s iconic music festivals. People more experienced than me in this area have provided the various reasons including:
- Poor scheduling
- Climate change/weather
- Insurance
- Technical and production costs
- Social media and live streaming
- General cost of living expenses
- Policing / security
- International parity with the Australian dollar
As a footnote; one of the world’s most famous festivals is also struggling… the story about Coachella and the fact that in 2022 the tickets for both weekends sold out within 40 minutes. For 2024, tickets for the second week are still open. Coachella is seeing the slowest ticket sales in 10 years!
I am sure all these factors have contributed, some more than others, and there is a call for governments to step in and underwrite future festivals. I can’t see that happening and I wouldn’t be a supporter simply because many of the festivals are owned by one of the world’s largest entertainment companies. It’s the smaller operations that are impacted the most. In any case, how do you justify underwriting an event that may or may not be financially viable in the first place?
It seems we will see a change in the style of public festivals offered. Maybe more niche events to cater to a specific demographic rather than the really big ones.
So, what do we do to address the key issues raised by these examples? Hold every public event indoors to reduce potential weather, production, insurance and security costs? We all know this is not a real long-term solution, but the students came up with the following key points:
- There needs to be a greater emphasis on the risk-related issues with an event and the potential cost implications – no matter the size and complexity of the event right up front and not just a box you tick later.
- They all agreed it is not a matter of “if something might happens” but “when something will happen”. This point alone is a major change in the mindset, but it is now the way all event planning has to be approached.
As a footnote, if you ever wanted to see the very fine line between risk and an artist’s performance, have a look at the current Astroworld civil suit in the US. The artist – Travis Scott is saying “it is not my problem that 10 people were killed in a crowd crush.” The risk people were saying “this is going to end in a disaster”. Tragic examples like this have a major impact on a global scale.
While this might seem somewhat pessimistic, the silver lining lies in the evolution of our industry over the past 15-20 years. Looking back there were few major risk assessment protocols in place; we simply didn’t give it adequate consideration or think about the potential impacts of unforeseen circumstances. Serious discussions at any level rarely took place and I, like many others, was guilty in the oversight. The greatest risk we considered then was wet weather and if we needed ponchos on standby! There are some things I did back then that I would not even contemplate today due to the risk implications. To be fair, the world we live in today is vastly different and that simply reflects on how events are designed and implemented.
Our tertiary institutions are much better at highlighting these changes today in the industry and this is reflected in the way students are looking at these current issues like the ones discussed here. We are not going to be able to solve every issue facing the industry, but a wider lens will help minimize the impact of these elements that can cause one of our events to go Arghh!!
Like the students who took part in this exercise, we welcome your comments and thoughts.




Quite well summarised Peter and the students need credit for their insightfulness.